Vinyl Sleeves

Paper sleeves vs plastic sleeves | What’s best for Vinyl Records?

Understanding the Importance of Record Sleeves

Before delving into the comparison between paper and plastic sleeves, it is essential to understand the importance of record sleeves in preserving vinyl records. Record sleeves serve as a protective barrier, shielding vinyl records from dust, scratches, and other potential damage. They also help maintain the overall condition and value of the records.

Choosing the right type of sleeve is crucial for long-term preservation. The wrong choice can lead to irreversible damage, affecting the sound quality and overall value of the vinyl records. Therefore, collectors must consider various factors before making a decision.

Exploring Paper Sleeves for Vinyl Records

Paper sleeves have been the traditional choice for vinyl record collectors for many years. They offer several advantages that make them a popular option:

  • Non-reactive Material: Paper sleeves are made from acid-free materials, ensuring that they do not react with the vinyl records and cause any chemical damage.


  • Good Breathability: Paper sleeves allow the vinyl records to breathe, preventing the buildup of moisture and reducing the risk of mould or mildew formation.


  • Soft and Gentle: The soft nature of paper sleeves minimises the risk of scratches or scuffs on the vinyl records during insertion or removal.

Despite these benefits, there are some concerns and misconceptions associated with paper sleeves. One common concern is the possibility of paper sleeves causing paper scuffs or “rice paper” marks on vinyl records. While this can happen in certain cases, it is usually due to the presence of impurities in the paper or improper handling. By choosing high-quality paper sleeves and handling them with care, collectors can minimise this risk.

When selecting paper sleeves, it is crucial to opt for those made from acid-free and lignin-free materials. These materials ensure that the sleeves do not deteriorate over time and cause any harm to the vinyl records. Additionally, collectors should consider sleeves with poly-lined interiors, as they provide an extra layer of protection against static and dust.

Products you can choose from

Paper Sleeves for CD – Standard paper sleeves designed for CD protection, available in a convenient 100-pack.

7” Paper Sleeve With Hole : Single 7″ paper sleeves with a hole, providing simple and effective protection, available in white or black.

12” Paper Sleeve With Hole (White): White paper sleeves designed specifically for 12″ records, featuring a hole for easy access.

12” Black Paper Sleeve With Hole: Black paper sleeves tailored for 12″ records, equipped with a hole for convenient handling.

Paper sleeves with window & flap 100GSM : Coloured sleeve covers made from 100 GSM paper, featuring a window and flap design for a stylish and protective solution.

Analysing Plastic Sleeves for Vinyl Records

Plastic sleeves have gained popularity in recent years due to their durability and ease of use. They offer several advantages that make them a viable option for vinyl record collectors:

  • Enhanced Protection: Plastic sleeves provide a higher level of protection against dust, moisture, and other potential hazards.


  • Clear Visibility: Plastic sleeves are transparent, allowing collectors to showcase the album artwork and labels without removing the record from the sleeve.


  • Longevity: Plastic sleeves are more resistant to wear and tear compared to paper sleeves, making them a durable choice for long-term storage.

However, there are some considerations and potential drawbacks associated with plastic sleeves. One concern is the potential for the sleeves to trap moisture and create a humid environment, leading to mold or mildew formation. To mitigate this risk, collectors should opt for sleeves made from polyethylene or polypropylene, as these materials are less likely to retain moisture.

Another consideration is the static electricity that can build up in plastic sleeves, potentially attracting dust particles to the vinyl records. To address this issue, collectors can choose anti-static plastic sleeves or use anti-static inner sleeves in combination with the outer plastic sleeve.

When selecting plastic sleeves, it is important to choose those that are free from PVC (polyvinyl chloride). PVC sleeves can release harmful chemicals over time, damaging the vinyl records. Opting for PVC-free sleeves made from polyethylene or polypropylene is a safer choice for long-term preservation.

Products you can choose from

Record Dividers for 12″ Vinyl – Plastic dividers specifically designed for 12″ vinyl records, providing organisation and protection in a pack of 25.

12″ LP Vinyl Protector Card Sleeves – Card sleeves designed to protect 12″ LP vinyl records, available in various colours for added aesthetic appeal.

Card Sleeves for 7″ Vinyl Records  –  Safeguard your 7″ vinyl records with style, available in black,yellow, blue, green, pink, red, and purple options.

10″ Brown Card Record Sleeves : Preserve and protect your 10″ vinyl records with these durable 350gsm brown card sleeves.

12” LP Jacket with Hole – 10 pack: Safeguard your 12″ LP vinyl records in style with these 350gsm brown card sleeves, featuring a jacket design and a convenient hole for easy access.

Making an Informed Decision

Choosing between paper and plastic sleeves ultimately depends on the specific needs and preferences of the vinyl record collector. To make an informed decision, it is essential to consider the pros and cons of each option: 

Paper Sleeves Plastic Sleeves
Acid-free, breathable, soft and gentle on records Enhanced protection, clear visibility, longevity.
Possibility of paper scuffs, requires careful handling. Potential for moisture retention, static electricity buildup.


Collectors should consider the condition of their vinyl records, the storage environment, and their personal preferences when making a decision. For collectors who prioritize breathability and gentle handling, paper sleeves may be the preferred choice. On the other hand, collectors who prioritize enhanced protection and longevity may opt for plastic sleeves.

In some cases, collectors may choose to use a combination of both paper and plastic sleeves. For example, they may use paper sleeves for inner protection and plastic sleeves for additional outer protection. This hybrid approach allows for a balance between breathability and enhanced protection.

Regardless of the chosen option, it is crucial to handle the vinyl records and sleeves with care. Clean hands, proper insertion and removal techniques, and a clean storage environment are essential for maintaining the overall condition and value of the vinyl record collection.

The choice between paper and plastic sleeves for vinyl records is a matter of personal preference and specific requirements. By understanding the characteristics, benefits, and potential drawbacks of each option, collectors can make an informed decision that ensures the long-term preservation and enjoyment of their vinyl record collections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *